Shocking New Evidence Uncovers A New Person of Interest in the Black Dahlia Murder Investigation.
–Nina Martin, only 8-years-old, May Martin, just turned 12-years-old. Sisters missing near the Baldwin Hills of Los Angeles. Their bodies were not found for months. The neighborhood nightwatchman, S.C. Stone, was convicted of their murder and sentenced to death. Did this wrongful conviction and death sentence in 1925 leave a man free to kill little girls again 1937?
About the tragic 1937 murder case of three small children – two sisters and their friend. Melba Marie Everett and her little sister Madeline were playing in a park with their friend Jeanette Stephens when they disappeared near the Baldwin Hills of Los Angeles. “Feeble-minded” Albert Dyer was convicted of their murders. Concerned citizens were sure the wrong man was going to be hanged and they were certain they knew who the actual killer was. Uncivil Twilight, revealed how the prosecutors, lead detectives, the jury and many witnesses fought against the execution of S.C. Stone after what the California Supreme Court ruled was an “error-free” conviction. Then in 1937 many citizens thought they had a serial killer in Los Angeles, and that serial killer was responsible for the 1924 murders and the 1937 murders.
Virginia Brooks was missing for a month before her body was found. Was a serial killer responsible? The two little Martin sisters were murdered in 1924, and two more sisters in 1937, the Everett sisters along with their friend Jeanette Stephens. This third book details the facts surrounding this similar murder of little Virginia Brooks in 1931. The investigators did all they could with the science available to them, and tried so hard to follow trace evidence it is now a fascinating look into the history of forensic science, including entomology and horticulture. Are the 1924, 1931 and 1937 cases connected by a traveling serial killer?
While Albert Dyer was on trial for the murders of little sisters Madeline and Melba Everett and their friend Jeanette, another shocking case on the other side of the United States terrified the nation. Little Joan Kuleba was the next little girl to suffer at the hand of a possible serial killer, and she definitely suffered a lack of justice when the wrong man was convicted of her murder. Here it is, the entire record on appeal, spelling out how justice bent on tunnel vision abandoned a 4-year-old murder victim. This is the fourth book in The Colder Case Series, colder because little girls are murdered and colder because when the wrong person is sentenced to death, the case is still unsolved and the real killer is still free to kill again.
Book 5: The heartbreaking murder of little Geneva Hardman in 1920 Kentucky leads to the first time a state tried to stop a lynch mob in the South. First the state militia then martial law under U.S. troops are called with orders to protect Will Lockett, the “Negro” criminal defendant. Death and destruction ensue.
At only 12-years-old Jesse Pomeroy maimed and mutilated six little boys. After spending a short time in reform school he was released and he tortured and murdered two more children, a 10-year-old girl and a 4-year-old little boy. He was sentenced to death and his sentence was commuted to life in solitary confinement starting at age 14. Solitary was strict solitary. While previous books in the Colder Case Series explore these ghastly crimes against children from different points of view, this one reveals that issues then were the same issues we debate today. This account ends with a possible solution that could subdue the never-ending pendulum of crime and punishment swinging back and forth in extreme degrees. While the depictions of the brutal crimes are difficult to stomach, the analysis then and now is worth exploring.
Sometimes The Third Degree reads like a Dashiell Hammett story, sometimes it has the voice of Joe Friday in “Dragnet” and it is always true crime through and through.
Readers of the previous volumes in The Colder Case Series will already understand why The Third Degree is included in the series. Still, it might not be as clear as it could be just how brutal the third degree was. Even today it is shocking how many wrongful convictions are due to false confessions. Indeed, the Innocence Project recently freed its 350th person exonerated by DNA, many from death row, and its website reveals insights into how it can happen in our enlightened criminal justice system of today:
“Astonishingly, more than 1 out of 4 people wrongfully convicted but later exonerated by DNA evidence made a false confession or incriminating statement.”
Imagine when the third degree was rampant: black jacks, suspects kept awake for days without food or water. Beatings. There had to be countless false confessions.
In the early 1930’s Edwin M. Borachard documented many cases of wrongful convictions. He writes in the preface of this public domain book the following: “A district attorney in Worcester County, Massachusetts, a few years ago is reported to have said: ‘Innocent men are never convicted. Don’t worry about it, it never happens in the world. It is a physical impossibility.’ The present collection of sixty-five case, which have been selected from a much larger number, is a refutation of this supposition.”
Multiply that to the Nth degree, thanks to the Innocence Project. According to The National Registry of Exonerations – which does not require DNA proof like the Innocence Project does – Currently 2,491 exonerations More than 22,010 Years Lost! (Last visited, September, 2019.)
Borchard, though a law professor, writes in a conversational style and the cases he covers are fascinating. Don’t miss this prequel to today’s discovery of wrongful convictions.
Other books worth reading:
My readers will not want to miss this account of the Baldwin Hills murders of the little girls researched in Colder Case. It is by a relative of the two sisters. The book description:
In the summer of 1937, with the Depression deep and World War II looming, a California triple murder stunned an already grim nation. After a frantic week-long manhunt for the killer, a suspect emerged, and his sensational trial captivated audiences from coast to coast. Justice was swift, and the condemned man was buried away with the horrifying story.
But decades later, Pamela Everett, a lawyer and former journalist, starts digging, following up a cryptic comment her father once made about a tragedy in their past. Her journey is uniquely personal as she uncovers her family’s secret history, but the investigation quickly takes unexpected turns into her professional wheelhouse.
Everett unearths a truly historic legal case that included one of the earliest criminal profiles in the United States, the genesis of modern sex offender laws, and the last man sentenced to hang in California. Digging deeper and drawing on her experience with wrongful convictions, Everett then raises detailed and haunting questions about whether the authorities got the right man. Having revived the case to its rightful place in history, she leaves us with enduring concerns about the death penalty then and now.
A journey chronicled through the mind of a lawyer and from the heart of a daughter, Little Shoes is both a captivating true crime story and a profoundly personal account of one family’s struggle to cope with tragedy through the generations.
Emmett J. Scott’s preface: The Negro, in the great World War for Freedom and Democracy, has proved to be a notable and inspiring figure. The record and achievements of this racial group, as brave soldiers and loyal citizens, furnish one of the brightest chapters in American history. The ready response of Negro draftees to the Selective Service calls together with the numerous patriotic activities of Negroes generally, gave ample evidence of their whole-souled support and their 100 per cent Americanism. It is difficult to indicate which rendered the greater service to their Country—the 400,000 or more of them who entered active military service (many of whom fearlessly and victoriously fought upon the battlefields of France) or the millions of other loyal members of this race whose useful industry in fields, factories, forests, mines, together with many other indispensable civilian activities, so vitally helped the Federal authorities in carrying the war to a successful conclusion. (1919)